Beware of Inflated Flashlight Lumen Claims

I’m sure you’ve seen them. I’m sure you’ve seen the sales pages. Impressive flashlights with even more impressive flashlight lumen claims.

The Hype

This is where you’ll see something similar to this; hype word on digital screen background with world map

“Super-Bright LED Flashlight. Zoom lens with 1200 lumen CREE LED. Great for camping, hunting and fishing”.

Then in the product description there will be a laundry list of other impressive specifications. Or in some advertisements, they’ll be very little further explanation.

Regardless of the verbiage, the headlines will all have a similar tone. Certain keywords will often stand out. “Super” – “Super-Bright” –  “Extra Bright”  – “High Lumen” – “High Output” … etc, etc. bright light

But if this light in question is from an unknown manufacturer, OR, is for sale at what would appear to be an unusually steep discount, then it’s pretty safe to assume that what it CLAIMS, is NOT what you’ll get!

All that Glitters

Manufacturers (and sellers) know all to well that the average flashlight shopper is mainly shopping on the basis of brightness. Admit it, we all seek things that glitter! We’ll buy the shiniest diamond, even if the shine is only from a recent polish. We love those shiny cars in the showroom, even though that’s only good until a passing car splashes our new jewel with mud. So… why not shop for bright and shiny flashlights too!

Yes, they’re everywhere in these shiny little items. And they’ll advertise themselves, lumen-wise, anywhere from 600 to 1200. Here’s the problem though. Brightness is highly subjective, and it varies from eye to eye. Brightness (measured in lumens) is perceived in varying ways.

What You Are “Led” to Believe Print

In the case of LED flashlights, and again I’m mainly speaking of those whose price tag reeks the perception of “big discount”, these impressive lumen claims are usually bogus.

Here are some prime examples;

“300 lumen mini cree flashlight, adjustable zoom”

“flashlight CREE XM-L T6 LED, 1000 lumens”

“2000 lumen flashlight LED CREE T6 XML camping torch”

“CREE 2000 lumen XM-L T6 zoomable focus”

This is only a very small sample. The descriptions above are real, but every one of them is a 100% exaggeration of true performance. There is NO WAY those lumen claims are real. It is marketing hype, nothing more, nothing less. The sellers of these products prey on eager consumers who have absolutely NO experience in LED flashlights. In most cases, these products will arrive at your mailbox with NO documentation or instruction on how they are to be used.

Five Star Reviews

Here’s something that may surprise you. The majority of consumers who purchase these flashlights, give them 5 star reviews. smiley face

Most of the adulation will be “great”… “works good”… “best flashlight I’ve ever owned”… “super bright”… “love this light, I’ll be buying more”… “got two for myself and will be buying more as gifts”. 

The point is. They have no prior experience with them. Bright is bright. And as long as the sales page where they clicked the “buy” button from, claimed the light was two thousand lumens…what do they have to compare it to? As long as it works, (although sometimes they don’t) and looks reasonably bright, they’re satisfied. But what they’ve received, is not what was promised. Many of these eager buyers are even confused as to what type of battery the light uses.

Buyer Remorse

Sprinkled among those happy customers will be a few others who’ve been unfortunate enough to receive the “lemons of the basket”. Here, the adulation is less than enthusiastic; “complete junk”… “do not buy this product”… “worked for one day”… “came out of the package broken”… “not very bright”… “no where near (xxx)lumens” etc, etc.

It’s All About the Brand

As was discussed in a previous post about cheap flashlights, if you want quality, while at least getting CLOSER to the actual (promised) lumen output…you NEED to shop the reputable brands.

  • Fenix
  • Olight
  • Sunwayman
  • Jetbeam
  • Nitecore
  • Thrunite
  • Eagletac
  • Zebralight
  • Surefire

….just to name a few.

Ultrafire flashlights and batteries are EVERYWHERE! The problem is, just about ANY Chinese manufacturer can label their light, (or battery) Ultrafire. And eight times out of ten, it’s not an “official” Ultrafire…if that even means anything in itself.

What’s even worse, is that other makers use variations on that name. Virtually ANYthing as long as it has “fire” in the name, can be used. More than 95% of the time, these products are complete garbage! The drivers will blow-out. The parts will become weak. The springs will break. They aren’t waterproof, and they’ll become useless if dropped more than a few times onto a hard surface.

Even though some of the name-brands have been known to fail, at least MOST of them come with a warranty. Plus, with included manuals, there’s NO mistake about how to operate it and what type of batteries it accepts.

Just remember; when it comes to cheaply made parts… garbage in, garbage out.

If you’d like to see what I’ve tested, then take a look at my Products Review page!

 

If you have a question or a comment…I’d love to know!

 

 

 

Was this article helpful?
Sign up and receive free updates straight to your inbox. I will never share or sell your email address with anyone.
If you like this article, SHARE IT 🙂

4 Comments:

  1. Hi Ben.

    I recently bought a headlamp and when I bumped my head, the thing broke. It was also a claim that it was the best in the market.

    If we buy a flashlight, what should we really look at when we want quality?

    • Hello and thanks for the question!

      Quality runs in many forms, and it also depends on what you want it for, and whether it will be used for light or heavy duty work. Basically you can’t go wrong with a brand-name light. It’ll cost you upwards of $30… depending on your battery choice. You’re paying for quality and features, plus it’ll have a warranty if something DOES go wrong. This article named several of the good brands to look for when shopping.

  2. Reviews help but only if 99% of the reviews are 5 star. Stay away from lumen claims for the above reasons. If you see lumen stay away unless it has been tested by ANSI. Rather than lumen posting, check to see how the light preforms like distance, run times, waterproof,cold etc. These are easily proved or disproved, you will not need a lumens meter to check for that.
    Actually, the best headlamp on the market is Night Eyes. They are marketed for hunting but believe me they great for camping, night fishing, horseback riding and more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *